Homemade Pie Crust

This is a pie crust recipe from my Nanna (my Father’s mother). I heard that often she used seltzer water, or orange juice in place of the water in her recipe, but never milk. I have not tried either, as of yet, just water.

This is a pie crust recipe for a 9″ or 10″ pie crust pan, for both single and double crust pies.

If you are going to make two, two crust pies, don’t double the recipe, make it twice.

1 Crust Pie

  • 1 1/2 cups of all purpose flour
  • 3/4 tsp salt
  • 1/2 cup vegetable shortening (Crisco it what I use)
  • 1/4 cup cool water (little less than an full 1/4 cup)

2 Crust Pie

  • 2 3/4 cups of all purpose flour
  • 1 1/4 tsp salt
  • 9/10 cup of vegatable shortening (basically, not an entire cup)
  • 1/2 cup cool water (little less than a full 1/2 cup)

Measure out the pre-sifted flour. Then re-sift in the salt.

In a large mixing bowl cut in the vegetable shorening until it starts to look like corn meal with still a decent amount of loose flour.

Fill up the appropriately sized measuring cup for the water. Hold it in your hand with your fingers covering the top of the container and your thumb on the bottom. With your fingers, mostly held tightly together turn, your hand over and evenly sprinkle about 1/2 of the water over the flour and shortening mixture. Gently, turn over the mixture with a spatula, and then repeat with the remainder of the water.

Turn it over again with the spatula and then turn out the mixture into a large sheet of wax paper. It will look like there is no way that this will stick together to make a crust as it pour out as more of a pile with a seemingly vast amount of loose flour. Push to mixture together with your hands to form a ball and then pull up the edges of the wax paper around it to make a sack. Compress the mixture in the wax paper into a ball fairly firmly and twist the top of the wax paper so that you now have a fairly spherical blob.

Put in the refrigerator for 30 minutes.

While in the refrigerator, tear off two fairly (long 24″ or so) sheets of wax paper. For each sheet, put about 1/2 tsp of flour on the paper and rub it over the entire surface. Rub a piece of cold butter over the entire inner surface, and edge of the pie pan, then with your hands smear around the butter so that it melts a little and covers the entire surface.

Remove the mixture from the fridge unwrap it. If this is a double-crust pie, cut the ball into 3/5th and 2/5th sections. The 3/5th section is for the bottom, and the rest for the top.

Press mixture to roll out onto the floured side of one of the pieces of wax paper so that it is starting to form a disc about 1 1/2 to 2″ thick, then place the other sheet of wax paper, floured side down, onto the crust. Then roll it out to the desired diameter to match your pan. I will typically hold the pie pan over the crust as I am rolling to it to check the size and stop when the crust is about 3″ or so larger on all sides.

Then, gently peel the top piece of wax paper from the crust. This never goes perfectly for me, and sometimes, tears the crust a little and/or takes a thin layer of it with it in some places so don’t worry about it if it doesn’t separate easily, or cleanly. Then (depending on whether your are right or left-handed, I am right-handed), position your pie pan to the right of the rolled out crust. Grab the left-hand edge of the wax paper with your left hand and place your right hand on the rolled-out dough. Lift the wax paper with your left hand, flipping it over top of the pie pan to your right so that your right hand is now palm up over the pan directly touching the crust. Then position the crust over the pan and slip your hand out from under the crust.

This is the tricky part, and again, it never goes perfectly for me. With the crust draped over the pan, start peeling the wax paper off wherever it seems easiest. It will likely tear in places, and/or the wax paper wil take a thin layer of it with it in some places, but do your best to get it off in one piece.

Once separated, use any chunks that have fallen off the edges to repair any rips and pinch up the remainder around the edge for form a nice crust.

Then, dump in whatever filling you desire and bake away.

This crust tends to cook best between 375 F and 400 F, but depending on your oven and the pies you make, your mileage may vary.

If making two single crust pies, you can double the recipe and then halve the mixture before rolling it out, but do not try to triple, or quadruple it because it does not come out right. Also, do not try to double the recipe for a double crust, just make however many separate batches for double-crust pies you are making.

2 thoughts on “Homemade Pie Crust

Leave a Reply